Prev 18 of 20 Next
Almay Oil-Free Makeup Eraser Sticks, $5
Unless you're a pro, we're guessing you're just like us and probably need a tidying up after applying your eye makeup (especially mascara—seriously, it gets all over our upper eyelid!). Enter Almay's affordable ($5 at oil-free makeup eraser sticks—cotton swabs with makeup remover built-in.